Whether or not Air Canada uses the right social media monitoring services (or, for that matter, is monitoring social media at all) is irrelevant in the wake of a disastrous public relations episode in which a 10-year-old boy’s wheelchair was damaged during a flight to New York City. It was only after Tanner Bawn’s troubles were picked up by the TwitterSphere that Air Canada scrambled to respond.
The episode drives home two points: Air Canada needs to do a much better job of monitoring the social media landscape, and Canadian companies, in general, are still not moving aggressively to take advantage of what social media has to offer as a communications, marketing, sales, customer service and crisis management tool.
A month ago, I did a post asking which Canadian companies were doing well at social media. The response in terms of comments and tweets was far from overwhelming. Sure, there are companies using it well but, overall, Canada is lagging behind in social media – much like we did in e-commerce and Web 2.0.
It is difficult to explain why Canadian companies have taken a cautious approach to social media given the amount of activity and the number of people on the bandwagon. Many Canadian companies are just starting to dip their toes in the water, while trying to figure out if its fits strategically and tactically with their other operations.
While it is important not to plunge into social media without a sense of what you want to do, your objectives and target audience, social media is something you just have to do at some point, particularly if you’re a consumer-facing company. Even putting a toe in water will provide companies with valuable experience of what works and what doesn’t so they can start to get a better handle on how they could have an effective social media presence.
Here’s some advice for companies thinking about getting into social media but not sure what to do:
1. Start by asking why why you want to social media. Is it because social media is all the rage? Does it offer obvious benefits in terms of marketing, communications and sales? Is the competition using it?
2. Establish what success looks like. It could be more sales, better customer service, a stronger brand or a new way to engage with existing and potential customers. Whatever the goal, select one that is relevant, and then measure against it.
3. Identity the target audience(s) and whether social media is how they are consuming information. If your customers don’t use Facebook, then Facebook may not be the best social media service to embrace.
4. Be realistic about the resources and people to make social media happen. As much as a good strategic plan is a necessity, many companies fail at social media because they don’t execute tactically. This means having people who can work social media on a day in, day out basis, regardless of how many services are being used. It means making sure the organization as a whole embraces and promotes social media so it’s not a siloed or orphaned activity.
5. Be patient. Social media success doesn’t happen overnight. I advise clients it takes about three to six months to get a good handle on what’s happening. During this period, companies must have a steady social media presence, provide good content (videos, photos, links, contests, etc.) and continually monitor and measure to make adjustments.
For any company looking for advice or answers about social media strategy and tactics, I’d be happy to happy to talk. Click on the contact link for more information.
http://postrank.com/graphics/blog_claim.png?s=285ay9w
You can add this with your blogging software, or use the following html code:

Hey Mark,
I’m glad things got resolved for Tanner and I’m a fan of Unmarketing. I do have some thoughts. You say in your post, “It was only after Tanner Bawn’s troubles were picked up by the TwitterSphere that Air Canada scrambled to respond.” Are you sure? From all other reports, the tweet from the Aunt came out of frustration, but Air Canada was working to get things fixed (see the article you linked to and the comments). I posted about this over the weekend (here: http://www.twistimage.com/blog/archives/the-real-time-web-is-a-big-problem-for-the-web/) – it is possible that the real-time Web creates unrealistic customer services expectations. We have a scenario here with something very complex (a custom built wheelchair) and a company (Air Canada) that still has to figure out what the problem is, how to get this fixed, where to get this fixed, get in contact with those who can fix it and see what their timeline to do so might be, and push this through from customer service up to someone who can get this resolved. Is it unrealistic that it takes a company several hours to figure out how to fix a custom-built wheelchair in New York City instantly? It’s not like they can just buy one at Target.
It sucks that Tanner had to go through this, but I’d love to know how long, traditionally, Air Canada would take to get this resolved versus the instant pressure from those on Twitter.
We’re quick to jump all over brands for not listening, but in this case, it seems like Air Canada was trying to make things right… and pretty quickly. OK, the manual chair wasn’t good and nor was the electric one they sent, but they seemed to be trying to get this resolved and it doesn’t sound like they were sitting around and ignoring the issue.
Has the real-time Web made us all a little unrealistic when it comes to customer service? I’ll know the answer by how long it takes you to respond to this comment
Mitch,
Thanks for the comment. You’re right (and this is a good topic for another post) about the expectations that people have about customer service now that they can use social media to quickly broadcasts their complaints. The impression that I got – and this may have been due to the slant of the media coverage – was that Air Canada took its time before getting involved but it may very well have been engaged quickly relatively speaking.
One of the big issues of social media and customer service is how consumers expect issues and problems to be resolved in ways that may not have happened before they could kvetch publicly. Rather than respond by telling consumers they’ve heard their complaints and will embrace them, many companies concede “defeat” by bending over backwards to make things right. This only fuels the social media customer service “fire”.
cheers, Mark
Air Canada Shines Spotlight on Timid Social Media Landscape | Mark … « Media Point
[...] here to see the original: Air Canada Shines Spotlight on Timid Social Media Landscape | Mark … Written on August 9th, 2010 & filed under TV Tags: Comentário, damaged-during, plight, [...]