Plagarism is Alive and Well

Images-1
Wordpress boss Matt Mullenweg believes spam is one of the blogosphere’s biggest threats but another increasingly troubling issue is plagiarism. We’re not talking about people taking the ideas of other bloggers but outright theft of entire posts or passages. A recent example is The Client Side, which had its posts ripped off without attribution or even a hat tip by Scott Kress, an experienced blogger who should know better. Over the weekend, several b5 bloggers noticed a blog called All Women Talk is using other people’s content without permission.

Within the media, plagiarists are treated like vermin and quickly ostracized. In the blogopshere, it seems many people are still trying to get their heads around plagiarism. On one hand, it can be somewhat flattering to have your content “borrowed” by someone else because it suggests what you’re writing is interesting. Many blogs using your content will try to get around it by linking back to your blog or giving you credit.

After awhile, you begin to realize you’re doing all the work while someone else is reaping the benefits (readership, traffic, advertising revenue) by scraping your content. Why should someone ever visit your blog if they can read it somewhere else? You soon realize the linkbacks are insincere tokens of thanks. Rather than giving you some props/credit, they’re a cheap and inadequate way of asking for permission.

So what can you do if another blogger is ripping off your work? You can start with a friendly comment or e-mail, suggesting that while you’re flattered by the attention, it would be better if they put together their own thoughts on a particular topic while citing the blog where they got the idea. If that doesn’t work, a harsher e-mail or a post on your blog outing the plagiarist may be the next move. In extreme cases, you can use the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, (DMCA) to compel people to take down seen to be infringing on copyrighted content.

For more information on plagiarism, check out Plagiarism Today, a blog that looks at plagiarism, content theft and copyright issues.

Technorati Tags:

Porn for Mobile Warrior

Featuring one of the best headlines I’ve seen in a long time – “Is that your cellphone in your pocket…?”, the National Post had a story a couple days ago about wireless carrier Telus quietly offering downloads of pornographic photos and videos for about $3 or $4 a shot You’ve got to love the explanation from Telus spokesman Jim Johannson, who said since porn is already widely available on mobile browsers, the carrier has “introduced — in a very responsible way — adult content that’s in behind proper age verification and that’s compliant with provincial standards and regulations.”

Ha! I guess that makes it alright. What Johannson should have said is: “Like any ARPU-hungry carrier, we’re looking for new ways to enhance wireless data revenue. Clearly, porn is a lucrative online business so it’s a no-brainer to serve consumers who want a mobile fix”. According to the Post, the North American mobile phone users spent $400-million on adult photos and video last year. No one should overlook the fact the porn industry is always on the bleeding edge of technology – be it VCRs, e-commerce, streaming video, DVDs and, now, wireless.

Technorati Tags: ,

The Monetization of User-Generated Content

So, YouTube’s going to start sharing the wealth, eh? I guess it’s easy to feel generous after you’ve pocked $1.65-billion from Google, and never have to work again. There’s lot of chatter about why YouTube is doing it (check out Scott Karp and Nick Carr for a small taste) but the bigger and far more interesting development is how the user-generated content industry is starting to become a business as opposed to a hobby/brand building/ranting/ego massaging exercise.

As Scott Karp makes clear, more people want to get paid for the content they produce (and we’re not talking about link love, trackbacks, RSS subscriptions and traffic). We’re talking dollars and cents (but mostly dollars given people are tired of getting cents from AdSense). Does this mark the beginning of the end of the user-generated content revolution that has seen millions of people offer their insight, knowledge and skills for free or next to nothing. Probably not but it does indicate the USG market is already starting to evolve as content producers are saying “show me the money”, while distributors (YouTube, Revver, etc.) look to embrace different ways to monetize their traffic to turn a cool, popular service into a business.

In theory, the concept of getting paid could be a could thing for USG because it could encourage people to create better content - if you believe in the concept this work will be more popular and, as a result, more lucrative. It’s content capitalism at work. Perhaps an ancillary benefit will be a consolidation of the USG industry as people who want to be paid but get nothing or little for their efforts decide to move on to other things.
Update: As much as money is coming into the user-generated content world, ego still plays a huge role in why people blog. Exhibit one is Robert Scoble, who detonated a flurry of discussion within the blogosphere after having a digital temper tantrum because after Engadget declined to link to a video story he did on new technology from Intel. Scoble’s not into blogging to make money (although it has jump-started his career in a major way) but his disappointment over the lack of links shows he’s got a healthy ego and his blog is part of that equation.

Technorati Tags: , ,

I was Hacked!

Computer hackers, viruses and phishing scams attack other people, right? It doesn’t affect the tech savvy, right? Well, I discovered the hard way that anyone is vulnerable to bad people online. It started about a week ago when someone tried to move a large amount of money out of my bank account. Fortunately, our tenant had bounced a rent check so there was actually no money in the account to be transferred out.

A few days later, the bank was able to tell me that the transfer request was made by Paypal, which was strange because I hadn’t made a major transaction involving Paypal. So, I called Paypal to see what was up. To make a long story short, some people in England and Indonesia had somehow broken into my Paypal account, changed the e-mail information and the password, and taken the money out, which prompted Paypal to demand additional funds from my bank account.

The story has a relatively happy ending (at least for me). After an hour on the phone with a terrific customer service person from Paypal (I wish I had taken down her name so I could have pass along my compliments to her boss), everything was sorted out and my Paypal account will be restored.

Aside from making me feel extremely vulnerable and giving my Luddite-like wife yet another reason to scorn the Internet, this incident has really caused me to reconsider how much information I provide online, where it’s stored, who has it and what I can do to be smarter. Given I’ve been actively online for 10 years, it may be late in the game for me to “clean the slate” entirely, but I’m definitely going to be more cautious about who gets my information in the future.

Note: Speaking of viruses, there’s an interesting post from the person who wrote the first computer virus 25 years ago, while Web Worker Daily has a post looking at people should be careful about giving personal information to Web 2.0 services. Mathew Ingram writes about Microsoft looking to get into the micro-payments business so it could compete against Paypal and Google Checkout.

Technorati Tags: ,

We’re….Talking Tech

Talking Tech-2
Kevin’s in Montreal (apparently on business) so tech analyst Duncan Stewart was good enough to fill in. The major theme of this week’s Talking Tech podcast is Microsoft, which had an up and down week. First, the bad as Microsoft (or, at least one, of its employees) was thrust into the spotlight after trying to hire an Australian journalist to “correct” some Wikipedia entries. So did Microsoft do anything wrong other than getting caught? After all, companies spend billions of dollars on public relations, marketing and advertising to create a message, and I’m sure many companies are quietly tweaking Wikipedia entries.
Of course, Microsoft can point to fiscal second-quarter results that met expectations, as well as bullish guidance. Mind you, Microsoft’s results continue to driven by old standards – Windows and Office – while its entertainment and online services divisions continue to bleed. (See Seeking Alpha for a break out of the results). It really is a mystery why Microsoft is unable to make money from its new business ventures.

From a personal perspective, Forrester’s report on the ROI of Blogging is interesting because it attempts to define the benefits that companies can get from blogging. Give Forrester credit for trying to provide companies with a higher level of comfort when it comes to blogging. That said, Forrester is throwing a small stone in a sea of corporate caution given many companies are still trying to get a handle on the benefits of blogging, let alone the content that the blogs should feature and who should them (the CEO? The VP of Marketing? The head of PR?)

Click here for the show notes. Thanks to David Jones, Ed Lee and Neil Johnson for their production expertise.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

More Blog Thoughts: Kill “Blog”

Another thought about blogs and blogging. One of the major hurdles that many people need to overcome is getting their heads around the idea of a “blog”. “What’s a blog?” is a question I hear on a regular basis when talking to people outside the echo chamber. Maybe we should adopt a term such as “dynamic Web sites” or “Live Web sites” – something that gives people a better idea about how a blog functions.
Update: The 2007 bloggies (what’s a bloggie?) have been announced. As part of the entry requirements, it defines a blog as “a page with dated entries”.

Technorati Tags:

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...